Hydrogen is seen as central to the green transition, but overreliance on ‘green’ hydrogen could hinder Europe’s climate goals by diverting renewable energy from grid decarbonisation. What are the risks of high Renewable Fuels of Non-Biological Origin (RNFBO) deployment, and how could it impact the EU’s decarbonisation strategy?
About the report
The EU’s amended Renewable Energy Directive (RED III) targets an increase in the share of renewables from 24.5% in 2023 to 42.5% by 2030, with ambitious sectoral sub-targets for RFNBO use in industry and transport. However, without stringent regulation, RFNBO deployment could cause emissions to flatline rather than decrease.
The report models different scenarios to assess the impact of hydrogen production on the electricity grid, quantifying ‘induced’ emissions associated with RNFBO production and comparing RFNBO use with alternatives like direct electrification or the displacement of fossil fuel-based electricity in the grid.
It shows that while producing hydrogen with a low carbon footprint is possible, when induced emissions are counted, the carbon footprint of RFNBOs can be very high.
Key findings
Hydrogen production can increase emissions
RFNBO production could generate more emissions than fossil-based hydrogen as it tends to divert renewables from decarbonising the grid.
In a highly interconnected EU grid, these ‘induced’ emissions could be even higher.
Direct electrification is more efficient
Electrifiying sectors such as transport is much more energy-efficient than relying on RFNBOs and should be prioritised where possible.
Hydrogen should be used strategically
RFNBOs should be prioritised for industries that already depend on fossil-fuel hydrogen, like ammonia and methanol production.
Policy adjustments are needed
Revise RED sub-targets to encourage energy-efficient solutions such as electrification more than hydrogen use.
Better emissions accounting in the RFNBO standard, to account for induced emissions.
Revised RFNBO standard to only make eligible hydrogen produced without induced emissions.
Related publications
Towards a minimum recycled steel content in passenger cars: setting an initial target
The EU has around 286 million motor vehicles, and every year, 6.5 million of these are scrapped. If the steel scrap from these end-of-life vehicles (ELVs) is not managed well, valuable resources are lost, harming the environment. With the EU preparing its ELV Regulation, which could set targets for minimum recycled steel content for passenger cars : what should those targets be?
Feedback on the EU Commission’s draft methodology for low-carbon hydrogen
For ‘low carbon’ hydrogen to truly make a positive contribution to Europe’s transition to climate neutrality, the safeguards put in place must be meaningful. Unfortunately, this does not appear to be the case in this draft delegated act.
Metallurgical flexibility: Enabling the aluminium and steel sectors for demand response
Electrification and flexibility are critical to decarbonising both industrial and electricity systems. But what happens when we combine the two? Industrial flexibility will play an increasingly important role as industry moves towards electrification.
Mundo Matogné. Rue d’Edimbourg 26, Ixelles 1050 Belgium. Sandbag is a not-for-profit (ASBL) organisation registered in Belgium under the number 0707.935.890. EU transparancy register no. 277895137794-73. VAT: BE277895137794-73